Jamestown Pie Company

Note: The owner or a representative of this business has not yet completed the verification process

See more Terms of Service

4.5

( 8 reviews )

Bakery, Grocery store $$

1804 Jamestown Rd, Williamsburg, VA 23185, United States

+1 7572-297-775

Introducing Jamestown Pie Company, a popular pizza restaurant located at 1804 Jamestown Rd, Williamsburg, VA. Known for its delicious assortment of sweet and savory pies, sandwiches, pizza, and ice cream, Jamestown Pie Company offers a diverse menu for its patrons. From the mouth-watering creole pie with chicken, shrimp, and sausage to the delectable pecan pie and apple crumb pie, there is something for every pie enthusiast. Whether dining in, taking away, or opting for delivery, Jamestown Pie Company provides a delightful dining experience. With a 4.5-star rating and rave reviews from patrons, it's clear that Jamestown Pie Company has made a mark in the culinary scene of Williamsburg, Virginia. So, whether it's a savory pot pie or a sweet apple crumb pie, Jamestown Pie Company is a must-visit for pie lovers.

Amenities and More

Dessert
Credit cards
Free parking lot
Plenty of parking
Outdoor seating
Comfort food
Tourists

Reviews

4.5/5

8 reviews

5 stars

4 stars

3 stars

2 stars

1 stars

Lyree adams

March 22, 2024

This is not a New York slice. And you know what. I'm ok with it. It's still a thin crust. It still has a good bite. The crust holds up to the toppings. It's delicious. The crust is so unique. It's soft and crisp at the same time. Like the top of pot pie. This is the kind of place that celebrates ingredients. The mushrooms and spiach were fresh, not frozen. Their pies aren't fancy, just delicious. I think this place was a cool place for an outdoor pizza picnic. And hey! They have pies!

Maya b.

March 22, 2024

Mouth-watering chicken pot pie, the best hands down in this world! We drive an hour to get to this hidden gem. We also tried their chicken pizza today first time, yummm! We get baklava every time as well, no regrets. This is the place!

Edumar macías

March 22, 2024

Over 20 years ago I was introduced to this little pie company. Everything was amazing. I ordered my favorite the chocolate pecan pie for the holidays and had it delivered. It arrived on time and was simply amazing. Everyone raved about how delicious it was. Thank you for always exceeding expectations! 5 stars isn’t enough!

Dev dav

March 22, 2024

Probably one of the best pie we ate. The crust is perfect and everything inside is delicious. From savory to sweet. So many choices. Their cheesecake is also really good. Would love to come back to enjoy some more

Face kicker

March 22, 2024

This is a take-out place. There is outdoor seating. The pies are so good! We got a chicken and veggie pot pie to go, partially cooked made that just needed to be baked at 350° for 30 minutes. We could also have gotten it frozen or fully cooked.

Lambert tooba

March 22, 2024

Fantastic fruit and pizza pies! Delicious cheese and toppings on Sicilian pizza, and pies are second to none - both clear examples that they only use top quality ingredients in their products. Baklava was fantastic as well! Fast and friendly service.

Julia buchheister

March 22, 2024

The savory seafood pot pie was so good! The seafood is cooked perfectly, mounded up high inside a delicious pie shell and the sauce it's in is delicious! Also got 2 sweet pies. Unfortunately, they don't have very many of their pies available in slices so we ended up with the coconut custard (very good) and the chocolate peanut (wanted the chocolate pecan but they only had that as a whole pie). The chocolate peanut didn't really have any chocolate and the peanuts would have been better if they were chopped. They were whole and kind of tough to chew. Overall, would definitely go back for the savory pie and would try other sweet pies.

Francis yau

March 22, 2024

Very cozy, mom and pop feel and the customer service was top tier. The cheese cake is solid and their pepperoni pizza is on point. Will gladly go back.